Sometimes 'I'm not a morning person' is the fox's line about the grapes

Jon Elster's 1983 account of adaptive preferences suggests that some people who say they dislike mornings stopped wanting them after repeated failures. Chronotype is real, but the test is whether the dislike predates the failures.

In Aesop’s fable, a fox leaps at a bunch of grapes, misses, and walks off saying they were sour anyway. Jon Elster used the story as the title of his 1983 book Sour Grapes, to name a quiet kind of self-deception: a preference that shifts to match what the person has found out they cannot have. He called it adaptive preference formation, and stressed that it happens “behind the back” of the person, so the fox does not know it is doing it.

Now read “I’m just not a morning person” with that in mind. Chronotype is real and partly inherited, so for many people the sentence is a plain report, and the genetics of being a morning person is not in dispute here. But for someone who tried 6 a.m. four times in a spring, lost each time, and then decided mornings were never their thing, the sentence may be the fox’s.

A teenager’s late body clock does not settle the matter, since adolescents as a group drift late, so “I was a night owl at sixteen” proves little. A better clue is the order of events. Say, hypothetically, that someone tries 5:30 a.m. in March, April and May, quits each time within ten days, and only in June starts calling mornings overrated. The dislike arrived after the losses, and the fox’s version of a preference often does. A person whose dislike was already there at the first attempt, and who felt worse at 5:30 than they did at 6:30 on the very first day, has better evidence for a real tendency.

Elster set this apart from deliberate “character planning”, where a Stoic trains themselves to want less on purpose and knows it. The fox does not know. I cannot tell you which one you are, and neither can you from the inside, which is Elster’s point. A cheap check is to write down what you said about mornings the year before your first serious try.

Keep reading