We Asked Support to Rank the Best Excuses for a Missed Streak

Somebody reads every “my streak broke and it wasn’t my fault” message that comes into an accountability app’s support inbox. We got five minutes with a composite of that job — built from patterns across real tickets, not one specific person’s inbox — for the rankings nobody official would ever publish. Calling her Dana.

Straight to it: what’s the excuse you’ve heard the most?

Dana: “My phone died overnight.” By a mile. It’s not even close. I’d guess it’s a third of every appeal we get.

Does it usually check out?

Dana: Sometimes. Phones do die. But we can usually see the account’s activity pattern, and “phone died” clusters suspiciously around exactly the mornings someone also, separately, tells a friend they were out too late. I’m not accusing anyone of lying to us specifically. I’m saying the timing is not subtle.

What’s an excuse that actually always checks out?

Dana: A time zone screwup on a real trip. Someone flew somewhere, the app or their phone didn’t reconcile the new zone fast enough, and their 6:30 fired at what was actually 4:30 local. We can usually verify that from the account’s location data and it’s genuinely not their fault — it’s a real product edge case, not an excuse.

Rank these for me: dead phone, overslept through the alarm, “forgot to charge it,” and food poisoning.

Dana: Food poisoning first, easily — people don’t usually fake that one, and honestly if you’re that sick the streak shouldn’t matter to anyone including us. Then dead phone, genuinely 50/50 whether it’s true. Then “forgot to charge it,” which is dead phone’s less convincing cousin — same claim, but framed as your own oversight instead of the universe’s, and somehow that framing makes people more likely to actually mean it. Last, “overslept through the alarm,” which isn’t really an excuse at all, it’s just naming the thing that was supposed to not happen.

Is there an excuse that’s technically true but doesn’t help the person’s case?

Dana: “I turned it off in my sleep and don’t remember.” That one’s almost certainly true — it’s a documented thing that happens — and it’s also exactly the failure mode the whole product exists to catch. Telling us the safety net didn’t work isn’t a case for an exception. It’s a case for a second alarm.

What’s the most creative excuse you’ve ever gotten?

Dana: Someone said their dog unplugged the charger overnight by chewing the cord, phone died at 40%, alarm never fired. They sent a photo of the chewed cord as evidence. I believed it completely and I still don’t know what to do with that level of commitment to an appeal.

Do excuses actually work? Does anyone get their streak reinstated?

Dana: Rarely, and it’s usually not because we were moved by the excuse — it’s because we can see something in the account data that corroborates a real technical failure, like the time zone case. An excuse with no corroborating evidence basically never changes an outcome on its own, no matter how well-written it is. People spend real effort crafting a good appeal message when a two-line factual account of what actually happened would do just as well.

What’s the one thing you wish people understood before they even message support?

Dana: That the streak breaking isn’t a referendum on you as a person, and we’re not trying to catch you in a lie — we’re trying to figure out if something on our end failed. The tone of most messages is defensive before we’ve said anything, which tells me people expect judgment that, at least from this side of the inbox, isn’t really the job.

Last one — best piece of actual advice, not an excuse, you’d give someone who keeps losing streaks to genuinely bad luck?

Dana: Redundancy, always. A second alarm on a second device catches almost every “my phone died” case before it becomes a support ticket at all. The people who never message us aren’t the people with better luck. They’re the people who stopped trusting one single point of failure a long time ago.

---

Would knowing which excuses actually hold up change how you’d explain a missed morning to whoever’s on the other end of your own streak? Worth asking them directly — most witnesses have opinions on this they’ve never been asked to share.

Dana’s actual fix — redundancy, not a better excuse — is worth taking seriously before you need it: a checklist built for a wake-up with zero margin for error shows what a real second device looks like, in case “my phone died” is currently doing more work in your own excuses than you’d like to admit. It’s also worth ruling out whether an overnight software update quietly broke the alarm before writing the whole morning off as bad luck.