I Removed My Backup Alarm for 60 Days and My Wake-Ups Got Worse Before They Got Better
What happens when you strip away the alarm safety net? A personal 60-day experiment with some unexpected findings about how multi-alarm dependency actually forms — and whether removing it is worth the rough first three weeks.
In this article5 sections
At 6:14 on a Wednesday in early March, I lay on my back watching the ceiling fan turn and had a simple decision to make: get up, or not.
My phone had one alarm set. It had fired four minutes ago. My previous system would have scheduled a second at 6:20, a third at 6:28, and a gentle fourth at 6:35 that I had never, in three years, actually needed. I’d removed all of them twenty-two days earlier as part of a documented experiment that I’ll be honest about: it started as a personal test and nearly derailed the first month of my work calendar.
Why I Tried It
The premise was simple. After reading Kenneth Wright Jr.’s published work on pre-waking arousal — Wright runs the Sleep and Chronobiology Lab at the University of Colorado Boulder and has studied how behavioral cues interact with the biological sleep-wake cycle — I wanted to know whether my backup alarms were a safety net or a dependency.
Wright’s research on anticipated waking describes how the body responds to expected waking times. When the brain treats a waking point as certain and fixed, it shifts toward lighter sleep stages in the lead-up hour — an anticipatory arousal that explains why some people wake naturally a few minutes before their alarm. This mechanism depends on the alarm being treated as a real boundary. When another alarm is coming, the anticipatory arousal is suppressed. The brain has learned there’s more time.
I had, over three years, trained my brain that 6:10 AM was a suggestion.
The First Two Weeks
They were rougher than I expected. On day 3, I slept through my alarm in that surface-level half-awareness where I registered the sound and filed it away as acceptable. I woke at 6:47, which cost me a writing session I’d planned for a week.
On day 11, I woke at 6:12, two minutes before my alarm — probably sleep stage coincidence. I logged it anyway.
The unexpected part: I started lying awake after 11:30 PM. Not dramatically, not anxiety-attack territory, but a low hum of ambient responsibility. The backup alarms had been absorbing that. When they were gone, the accountability for the morning settled somewhere in the pre-sleep window instead. My bedtime drifted forward by 22 minutes on average by day 14, according to my sleep tracker. Which was, on reflection, not the worst outcome.
What Changed Around Day 17
The ceiling-watching period got shorter. I started waking up 2–4 minutes before the alarm on most mornings — not consistently, not with any mystical precision, but with enough regularity to notice. By rough count, it happened on 19 of the final 43 days.
This isn’t a special alarm biology. The anticipatory arousal mechanism Wright describes simply started working again because the alarm had become a real boundary. The brain was paying attention because it had to.
The Honest Numbers
I tracked morning alertness on a simple 1–10 scale each day — how alert I felt by 8 AM, not at the moment of waking. This is imprecise and subjective. Still:
- Multi-alarm baseline (30 days before the experiment): average 5.8/10
- Single-alarm, days 1–14 (adjustment): average 4.9/10
- Single-alarm, days 15–60: average 7.1/10
The improvement is real enough to feel significant. It’s also confounded in ways I can’t fully isolate. Paying close attention to your wake quality for 60 days changes your behavior in ways that have nothing to do with alarm count. The earlier bedtimes may have mattered as much as the alarm change.
I genuinely don’t know which variable did the work. That’s worth saying plainly.
What I’d Recommend, Tentatively
If your backup alarms are genuine fallback insurance — you set them hoping never to need them — keep them. That’s not what I was doing.
If your backup alarms are a countdown timer that gives you permission to ignore the first alarm, the experiment is worth running. The first two weeks are the price.
The thing that made the biggest practical difference for me wasn’t the alarm change itself. It was telling someone I was doing it — a friend who asked how it was going on day 5 and day 12. The social exposure of the commitment did more than the mechanical change.
Worth asking yourself: if your backup alarms are a commitment problem wearing an alarm problem’s clothes, what would actually change that? DontSnooze builds a social accountability layer directly into the alarm — video proof of wake time, visible to someone who knows you set the target. That’s a different mechanism than removing a backup alarm, but it’s solving the same thing.
Related: